# Decision receipt cd5ada18b179

**ETH: no trade (judge decided no_trade)**

- Symbol: ETH  |  Source: `live`  |  Model: `qwen3-235b-a22b-instruct-2507` (prompts v3)
- Evidence hash: `fa5d228173cf9f38...`  |  Created: 2026-09-18T16:11:31+00:00

## Evidence availability

- `market_overview` (market_overview): **ok** | as_of 2026-09-18T16:09:07Z, data_mode live, trace db60754948b44ef48a6e542523a101a2
- `sentiment_shift` (monitor_market_sentiment_shift): **ok** | as_of 2026-09-18T16:09:08Z, data_mode live, trace 93d306f9a4bf4ab192a1acafcf9e2ddb
- `deep_analysis` (deep_analysis): **ok** | as_of 2026-09-18T16:09:54Z, data_mode live, trace 55c53ba0298a40eb9faf963db43244f5
- `analyze_token` (analyze_token): **ok** | as_of 2026-09-18T16:09:55Z, data_mode live, trace 9e2642dc398c46e3813bf8335bcef6bf
- `compare` (compare_tokens): **ok** | as_of 2026-09-18T16:10:33Z, data_mode live, trace 64578a5ec3cf42348f57d7db933fa643
- `price_check` (price_crosscheck): **ok** | as_of 2026-09-18T16:10:39+00:00, data_mode live, no RYO trace (Nota skill)
- `technicals_check` (technicals_crosscheck): **ok** | as_of 2026-09-18T16:10:40+00:00, data_mode live, no RYO trace (Nota skill)
- `positioning_check` (positioning_check): **ok** | as_of 2026-09-18T16:10:44+00:00, data_mode live, no RYO trace (Nota skill)

## Warnings

- deep_analysis: Optional Skill Hub token-profile evidence is incomplete or unavailable.
- compare: Optional Skill Hub token-profile evidence is incomplete or unavailable for one or more tokens.
- compare: The conclusion was calculated from the returned factors; no narrative model was used.
- technicals_check: reference RSI(14) 55.4 differs from independent 66.64 by -11.24 points
- positioning_check: withheld deep_analysis.data.derivatives.funding_rate_bps: not_token_specific (the same value 0 on AAVE, ADA, APT, ARB, ATOM, AVAX, BCH, BNB, BTC, DOGE, DOT, INJ, LINK, LTC, NEAR, OP, PEPE, SHIB, SOL, SUI, TRX, UNI, WIF, XRP the same day)

## Council

### macro | neutral (p_up_7d 0.50, confidence medium)
Broad conditions are risk-on with greed-level sentiment and strong market breadth, supporting upside potential. However, ETH lags peers in momentum and market activity, and mixed sentiment signals cap upside conviction. Conditions do not oppose ETH, but relative strength favors SOL.
- `market_overview.data.regime` = risk_on - Market regime is risk-on, supportive of risk assets.
- `market_overview.data.sentiment.fear_greed_index` = 73 - Fear & Greed at 73 indicates greed, reflecting elevated bullish sentiment.
- `market_overview.data.market.breadth` = 0.913 - Breadth of 0.913 shows 91% of large caps are advancing, confirming broad strength.
- `sentiment_shift.data.evidence.sentiment_regime` = mixed_sentiment - Overall sentiment regime is mixed, limiting conviction despite greed reading.
- `compare.data.factors.0.scores.SOL` = 9.05489 - SOL leads in 7-day momentum with +9.05%, outpacing ETH's +0.89%.
- `compare.data.factors.1.scores.SOL` = 0.084151 - SOL leads in market activity with 8.42% daily volume-to-cap ratio.
- `compare.data.factors.1.scores.ETH` = 0.056012 - ETH has moderate market activity at 5.6% volume-to-cap ratio.
- `compare.data.conclusion.pick` = SOL - SOL is ranked first in the peer comparison, with ETH as runner-up.
- Invalidation: If ETH’s 7-day momentum accelerates above 5% while market regime turns risk-off, the relative strength case would improve despite weaker macro.

### technician | neutral (p_up_7d 0.50, confidence medium)
ETH shows mixed momentum and sideways trend despite strong 30-day performance. RSI discrepancy and derivatives ambiguity limit conviction. Volatility is moderate but rising per independent check.
- `deep_analysis.data.technical_analysis.trend` = sideways - trend is sideways, not directional
- `deep_analysis.data.performance.d30` = 23.775 - 30-day momentum is strong at 23.77%
- `technicals_check.data.rsi_14` = 66.64 - independent RSI(14) 66.64 suggests overbought vs reported 55.4
- `technicals_check.data.atr_pct` = 3.992 - independent ATR(14) at 3.992% confirms moderate volatility
- `positioning_check.data.okx.oi_change_24h_pct_coin` = 1.7 - OKX open interest rose 1.7% in coins, minor long buildup
- `positioning_check.data.okx.long_short_percentile_100h` = 2 - long/short ratio at 2nd percentile, rare bearish skew
- `positioning_check.data.gate.0.verdict` = not_token_specific - funding rate withheld: not token-specific
- `price_check.data.reference.deviation_pct` = 0.095 - reference price within 0.095% of median, data quality ok
- Invalidation: A breakout above $2743 or sustained RSI above 70 would challenge the neutral stance.

### narrative | neutral (p_up_7d 0.50, confidence high)
ETH shows mixed signals: strong 30-day momentum and high volume support price gains, but sideways trend and neutral RSI limit bullish conviction. No clear catalyst or risk emerges from available data. Derivatives posture is non-threatening, yet open interest declined. Token profile gaps reduce confidence slightly, but market and technical data are consistent. Price may drift near current levels.
- `deep_analysis.data.performance.d30` = 23.775 - 30-day price change is +23.8%, indicating strong momentum
- `deep_analysis.data.technical_analysis.trend` = sideways - Trend is sideways, limiting directional conviction
- `deep_analysis.data.technical_analysis.rsi_14` = 55.4 - RSI at 55.4 suggests neutral momentum
- `deep_analysis.data.market.volume_24h_usd` = 1.77211e+10 - 24h volume exceeds $17.7B, signaling strong activity
- `deep_analysis.data.confluence.score` = 0.67 - Confluence score of 0.67 reflects mixed conditions
- `deep_analysis.data.derivatives.open_interest_change_24h_pct` = -6.33 - Open interest dropped 6.33% in 24h, suggesting reduced positioning
- _2 citation(s) dropped: path not present in evidence_
- Invalidation: A breakout above $2743 or breakdown below $2440 would shift the balance.

## Verdict: no_trade (p_up_7d 0.50)

All three council members are neutral with aligned 50% probability, and weighted confidence is moderate. Macro and technician cite risk-on regime and strong breadth, but ETH lags peers in momentum and activity (SOL leads). Technician flags RSI discrepancy (66.64 vs 55.4) and sideways trend. Narrative confirms mixed signals: strong 30-day momentum but declining open interest and neutral RSI. No clear catalyst or risk. Despite primary evidence being available, disagreement in RSI and lack of directional consensus support inaction.

- Risk: RSI interpretation differs between sources, reducing technical clarity
- Risk: ETH underperforms SOL in momentum and market activity

## Practice trade

- Blocked: judge decided no_trade

## What this cost

- 4 model calls, 19,503 prompt tokens, 1,595 completion tokens, 0.004122 USD as the provider billed it, in 47222 ms.

_Research on read-only RYO evidence. No order was placed. Not financial advice._