# Decision receipt ac70235f4eb8

**ETH: no trade (judge decided no_trade)**

- Symbol: ETH  |  Source: `live`  |  Model: `qwen3-235b-a22b-instruct-2507` (prompts v5)
- Evidence hash: `7153a50d4879199f...`  |  Created: 2026-09-29T21:07:37+00:00

## Evidence availability

- `market_overview` (market_overview): **ok** | as_of 2026-09-29T21:05:50Z, data_mode live, trace d74135b0881040d2967165be07720851
- `sentiment_shift` (monitor_market_sentiment_shift): **ok** | as_of 2026-09-29T21:05:50Z, data_mode live, trace 71ea849a810543fa9a2689fdd7cee8ef
- `deep_analysis` (deep_analysis): **ok** | as_of 2026-09-29T21:06:31Z, data_mode live, trace f4dcb7a02cf44a609b82d76e4a314bfa
- `analyze_token` (analyze_token): **ok** | as_of 2026-09-29T21:05:50Z, data_mode live, trace 24a97710431d44aa8e5dfab52444b688
- `compare` (compare_tokens): **ok** | as_of 2026-09-29T21:06:31Z, data_mode live, trace 75863bf1bb0e43a99ff77ccaa1ed9458
- `narrative_signal` (narrative_convergence): **ok** | as_of 2026-09-29T21:06:32+00:00, data_mode live, no RYO trace (Nota skill)
- `price_check` (price_crosscheck): **partial** | as_of 2026-09-29T21:06:34+00:00, data_mode live, no RYO trace (Nota skill)
- `technicals_check` (technicals_crosscheck): **ok** | as_of 2026-09-29T21:06:34+00:00, data_mode live, no RYO trace (Nota skill)
- `positioning_check` (positioning_check): **ok** | as_of 2026-09-29T21:06:35+00:00, data_mode live, no RYO trace (Nota skill)
- `liquidity` (liquidity_check): **ok** | as_of 2026-09-29T21:06:36+00:00, data_mode live, no RYO trace (Nota skill)
- `crowd_odds` (crowd_odds): **ok** | as_of 2026-09-29T21:06:36+00:00, data_mode live, no RYO trace (Nota skill)

## Warnings

- deep_analysis: Optional Skill Hub token-profile evidence is incomplete or unavailable.
- compare: Optional Skill Hub token-profile evidence is incomplete or unavailable for one or more tokens.
- compare: The conclusion was calculated from the returned factors; no narrative model was used.
- price_check: coingecko: HTTP 403
- price_check: binance: USDT used as USD proxy
- positioning_check: withheld deep_analysis.data.derivatives.funding_rate_bps: not_token_specific (the same value 0 on AAVE, ADA, APT, ARB, ATOM, AVAX, BCH, BNB, BTC, DOGE, DOT, INJ, LINK, LTC, NEAR, OP, PEPE, SHIB, SOL, SUI, TRX, UNI, WIF, XRP the same day)

## Council

### macro | neutral (p_up_7d 0.50, confidence medium)
Broad regime is neutral with greed cooling (68, down 10 pts), and breadth weak (45.65%). SOL leads in momentum and activity, limiting ETH's relative appeal. ETH’s 7-day stablecoin inflows (+0.3%) are offset by declining weekly TVL (-1.86%). Despite strong 30-day TVL (+8.43%) and stablecoin growth, near-term signals are mixed.
- `market_overview.data.regime` = neutral - Market regime is neutral
- `sentiment_shift.data.evidence.fear_greed.change_7d_points` = -10 - Fear & Greed down 10 points
- `market_overview.data.market.breadth` = 0.4565 - Breadth at 45.65%
- `compare.data.factors.0.winner` = SOL - SOL leads on momentum
- `compare.data.factors.1.winner` = SOL - SOL leads on market activity
- `liquidity.data.stablecoins.change_7d_pct` = 0.3 - ETH stablecoin supply +0.3% 7d
- `liquidity.data.tvl.change_7d_pct` = -1.864 - Ethereum TVL -1.86% 7d
- `liquidity.data.tvl.change_30d_pct` = 8.425 - Ethereum TVL +8.425% 30d
- Invalidation: A shift in momentum favoring ETH, or strong positive breadth and rising greed, would invalidate this neutral stance.

### technician | neutral (p_up_7d 0.50, confidence high)
ETH shows mixed signals: technical trend and momentum are up with RSI(14) at 61.7 and 30-day momentum at 8.66%, but 7-day performance is negative. Confluence confirms all gates, yet derivatives posture is neutral with balanced liquidation pressure and no clear funding signal. Cross-venue premium disagreement prevents positioning clarity. Independent technicals check confirms RSI and ATR are within acceptable variance, supporting data reliability.
- `deep_analysis.data.technical_analysis.trend` = up - trend is up
- `deep_analysis.data.technical_analysis.rsi_14` = 61.7 - RSI(14) at 61.7 indicates bullish momentum
- `deep_analysis.data.performance.d7` = -2.29278 - 7-day change is -2.29%, indicating recent weakness
- `deep_analysis.data.confluence.state` = CONFIRMED - confluence is CONFIRMED
- `deep_analysis.data.derivatives.liquidation_pressure` = balanced - liquidation pressure is balanced
- `positioning_check.data.okx.premium_state` = below_spot - OKX perp is below spot
- `positioning_check.data.hyperliquid.premium_state` = above_spot - Hyperliquid perp is above spot
- `technicals_check.data.reference.rsi_diff_points` = -1.38 - independent RSI check shows -1.38 pts difference, within tolerance
- Invalidation: A sustained break above $2827 or below $2547 would challenge the current neutral stance.

### narrative | neutral (p_up_7d 0.50, confidence medium)
ETH shows mixed signals: upward technical trend and strong volume support a bullish case, but 7-day price decline and low-confidence token profile with missing holder and TVL data cap upside conviction. No narrative momentum or derivatives risk detected.
- `deep_analysis.data.technical_analysis.trend` = up - Trend is up
- `deep_analysis.data.market.volume_24h_usd` = 1.50069e+10 - High 24h volume at $15B
- `deep_analysis.data.performance.d7` = -2.29278 - Price down -2.29% over 7 days
- `deep_analysis.data.derivatives.funding_trend` = stable - Funding trend is stable
- `analyze_token.data.technical_analysis.rsi_14` = 61.7 - RSI at 61.7, near upper neutral
- _3 citation(s) dropped: path not present in evidence_
- Invalidation: A breakout above $2828 with rising holder concentration and positive narrative coverage would increase p_up_7d to 0.7+.

## RYO said

- RYO said: neutral (confluence CONFIRMED) - council: no_trade, no comparison. RYO's driver: The measured market and technical signals are mixed.

## Verdict: no_trade (p_up_7d 0.50)

All council members (macro, technician, narrative) agree on a neutral stance with aligned p_up_7d = 0.5. Primary evidence is available and consistent, but no clear edge emerges. Technician reports high confidence, yet highlights mixed signals: bullish RSI(14)=61.7 and uptrend countered by negative 7-day performance (-2.29%) and conflicting perp premiums (OKX below, Hyperliquid above spot). Macro cites weakening greed and SOL outperforming in momentum and activity. Narrative flags incomplete token profile data, limiting conviction. No evidence invalidates neutrality.

- Risk: Cross-venue derivatives disagreement prevents clear positioning read
- Risk: Near-term TVL and 7d price decline offset longer-term TVL growth

## Practice trade

- Blocked: judge decided no_trade

## What this cost

- 4 model calls, 18,001 prompt tokens, 1,528 completion tokens, 0.003846 USD as the provider billed it, in 60761 ms.

_Research on read-only RYO evidence. No order was placed. Not financial advice._