# Decision receipt 43fe0cbf1716

**ETH: no trade (judge decided no_trade)**

- Symbol: ETH  |  Source: `live`  |  Model: `qwen3-235b-a22b-instruct-2507` (prompts v7)
- Evidence hash: `e9bdcf273db71016...`  |  Created: 2026-11-07T15:16:55+00:00

## Evidence availability

- `market_overview` (market_overview): **ok** | as_of 2026-11-07T15:14:27Z, data_mode live, trace 4bc1184a7af340a0859f462904a77966
- `sentiment_shift` (monitor_market_sentiment_shift): **unavailable** | as_of 2026-11-07T15:15:41Z, data_mode unknown, trace 8e97d1a9c17e4213bc356f1e74a468fa
- `deep_analysis` (deep_analysis): **partial** | as_of 2026-11-07T14:56:24Z, data_mode live, trace 4709ba6bdc284c95ba954e13bc1efe29
- `analyze_token` (analyze_token): **partial** | as_of 2026-11-07T15:15:42Z, data_mode live, trace 3416ee1aa7984ba1b50b4badc6ae4eba
- `compare` (compare_tokens): **ok** | as_of 2026-11-07T15:16:25Z, data_mode live, trace 7dac99ce768043debd39a9c66fc3d193
- `narrative_signal` (narrative_convergence): **ok** | as_of 2026-11-07T15:16:25+00:00, data_mode live, no RYO trace (Nota skill)
- `news_check` (news_verify): **ok** | as_of 2026-11-07T15:16:28+00:00, data_mode live, no RYO trace (Nota skill)
- `price_check` (price_crosscheck): **ok** | as_of 2026-11-07T15:16:30+00:00, data_mode live, no RYO trace (Nota skill)
- `technicals_check` (technicals_crosscheck): **ok** | as_of 2026-11-07T15:16:31+00:00, data_mode live, no RYO trace (Nota skill)
- `positioning_check` (positioning_check): **ok** | as_of 2026-11-07T15:16:33+00:00, data_mode live, no RYO trace (Nota skill)
- `liquidity` (liquidity_check): **ok** | as_of 2026-11-07T15:16:33+00:00, data_mode live, no RYO trace (Nota skill)
- `crowd_odds` (crowd_odds): **ok** | as_of 2026-11-07T15:16:33+00:00, data_mode live, no RYO trace (Nota skill)
- `onchain` (onchain_check): **ok** | as_of 2026-11-07T15:16:33+00:00, data_mode live, no RYO trace (Nota skill)
- `attention` (attention_check): **ok** | as_of 2026-11-07T15:16:33+00:00, data_mode live, no RYO trace (Nota skill)
- `network` (network_check): **ok** | as_of 2026-11-07T15:16:34+00:00, data_mode live, no RYO trace (Nota skill)

## Warnings

- sentiment_shift: Fear & Greed history is unavailable, stale, or incomplete.
- sentiment_shift: Funding history is unavailable, stale, or incomplete.
- sentiment_shift: Liquidation history is unavailable, stale, or incomplete.
- sentiment_shift: Altcoin-season context is unavailable or stale.
- sentiment_shift: The requested analysis is currently unavailable.
- deep_analysis: Technical indicators were not calculated; null values must not be treated as neutral or zero.
- deep_analysis: The Skill Hub returned no token profile for this token.
- deep_analysis: No preview trade plan could be calculated.
- analyze_token: Technical indicators were not calculated; null values must not be treated as neutral or zero.
- compare: Token profiles are incomplete or unavailable. BTC: The Skill Hub returned no token profile for this token. ETH: The Skill Hub returned no token profile for this token. SOL: The Skill Hub reported incomplete profile evidence: live holder coverage, BTC-relative 24h context, stable protocol-history deltas.
- compare: The conclusion was calculated from the returned factors; no narrative model was used.
- price_check: binance: USDT used as USD proxy
- positioning_check: bybit long/short: bybit: HTTP 403
- positioning_check: withheld deep_analysis.data.derivatives.funding_rate_bps: not_token_specific (the same value 0 on AAVE, ADA, APT, ARB, ATOM, AVAX, BCH, BNB, BTC, DOGE, DOT, INJ, LINK, LTC, NEAR, OP, PEPE, SHIB, SOL, SUI, TRX, UNI, WIF, XRP the same day)
- positioning_check: withheld deep_analysis.data.derivatives.open_interest_change_24h_pct: not_token_specific (the same value -11 on BNB, BTC, DOGE, PEPE, XRP the same day)
- attention: snapshot: nothing mapped for ETH
- network: hashrate: not applicable to ETH

## Council

### macro | bullish (p_up_7d 0.65, confidence low)
ETH leads peers in momentum despite neutral market regime and fear sentiment, supported by rising attention and stable network fundamentals, though declining DeFi TVL and stablecoin supply weigh as headwinds.
- `market_overview.data.regime` = neutral - Market regime is neutral, providing no directional bias.
- `market_overview.data.sentiment.fear_greed_index` = 32 - Market sentiment is in fear at 32, potentially contrarian-supportive.
- `compare.data.factors.0.winner` = ETH - ETH wins on momentum / relative strength among BTC, ETH, SOL.
- `attention.data.wikipedia.change_pct` = 51.4 - Wikipedia attention rose 51% recently, signaling growing interest.
- `network.data.coinmetrics.mvrv` = 1.0122 - MVRV of 1.01 suggests holders are at breakeven, reducing sell pressure.
- `network.data.coinmetrics.active_addresses_change_pct` = 4.52 - Active addresses up 4.5% YoY, indicating steady network use.
- `liquidity.data.stablecoins.change_7d_pct` = -2.238 - Stablecoin supply down 2.24% in 7 days, reducing on-chain liquidity.
- `liquidity.data.tvl.change_30d_pct` = -11.954 - Ethereum TVL down 11.95% over 30 days, signaling declining DeFi appeal.
- Invalidation: A drop below recent lows or sustained fee collapse would challenge the bullish case.

### technician | neutral (p_up_7d 0.50, confidence medium)
ETH shows mixed signals: sideways trend, neutral momentum, and elevated liquidation pressure. Independent technicals confirm RSI near 39.5 and ATR ~4.36%, aligning with reference. Price consensus is tight across exchanges, but perps trade below spot, indicating short-side eagerness. Onchain DEX and Chainlink prices align closely with reference. No clear directional bias.
- `deep_analysis.data.confluence.gates.0.detail.trend` = sideways - Trend is sideways per confluence analysis.
- `technicals_check.data.rsi_14` = 39.48 - Independent RSI(14) is 39.48, near neutral.
- `technicals_check.data.atr_pct` = 4.361 - ATR(14) is 4.361%, indicating moderate volatility.
- `positioning_check.data.okx.premium_state` = below_spot - Perpetuals trade below spot, signaling short-side demand.
- `positioning_check.data.okx.oi_change_24h_pct_coin` = -2.6 - OKX open interest dropped 2.6% in 24h (coin terms).
- `price_check.data.median_usd` = 2240.6 - Exchange median price is $2,240.60, tightly aligned.
- `onchain.data.chainlink.deviation_pct` = -0.027 - Chainlink feed deviates -0.027% from reference.
- `onchain.data.dex.deviation_pct` = -0.065 - DEX price deviates -0.065% from reference.
- Invalidation: A sustained break above $2,300 with rising open interest and RSI > 50 would shift bias upward.

### narrative | neutral (p_up_7d 0.50, confidence medium)
ETH sentiment is mixed: one bullish signal from WatcherGuru about Russia’s central bank approving ETH trading is uncorroborated by other voices and contradicted by broader market outflows and liquidations. On-chain accumulation by Bitmine (4.9% supply) provides structural support, but 30-day price decline and lack of technical confirmation keep outlook neutral.
- `narrative_signal.data.tokens.0.direction` = bullish - One voice expresses bullish sentiment.
- `narrative_signal.data.tokens.0.sentiment_mean` = 0.459 - Positive sentiment score from single mention.
- `news_check.data.distinct_domains` = 3 - Only three domains mention ETH, limiting narrative spread.
- `news_check.data.sources.5.snippet` = The attackers have used more than 20,000 wallets on 16 blockchains so far, but the bulk of the stolen ETH and Bitcoin hasn't moved. - Bitmine holds 4.9% of ETH supply, suggesting long-term confidence.
- `news_check.data.sources.3.snippet` = US spot Bitcoin and Ether ETFs shed a combined $530 million Thursday as Bitcoin fell below $76,000 and US stocks tumbled. - ETF outflows suggest weakening short-term demand.
- `news_check.data.sources.2.snippet` = Bitcoin fell 6% to $75,700 and ether 7% as a Nasdaq selloff hit crypto, triggering $1.03 billion in liquidations. - Over $1B in liquidations indicates recent market stress.
- `analyze_token.data.performance.change_30d_pct` = -10.6714 - ETH down over 10% in past 30 days.
- `deep_analysis.data.confluence.gates.0.detail.trend` = sideways - Price trend is sideways, not confirming breakout.
- Invalidation: A confirmed regulatory greenlight from a G20 nation or sustained inflows into ETH ETFs would shift the narrative positively.

## RYO said

- RYO said: neutral (confluence CONFIRMED) - council: no_trade, no comparison. RYO's driver: The measured market and technical signals are mixed.

## Verdict: no_trade (p_up_7d 0.55)

The council is split: macro (bullish, low confidence) cites momentum and attention gains, but technician and narrative (both neutral, medium confidence) highlight sideways trends, perp discount, ETF outflows, and liquidations. Primary evidence is mostly available, but sentiment_shift is unavailable and deep_analysis/analyze_token are partial, weakening technical conviction. Calibration weights favor technician (1.0) and narrative (0.964), whose neutral stances dominate. No clear edge emerges.

- Disagreed with: macro
- Risk: Stablecoin supply and DeFi TVL are declining (liquidity.data.stablecoins.change_7d_pct: -2.238, liquidity.data.tvl.change_30d_pct: -11.954).
- Risk: Perpetuals trade below spot, signaling short-side eagerness (positioning_check.data.okx.premium_state: below_spot).
- Risk: Recent 30-day price decline and $1B+ liquidations indicate stress (analyze_token.data.performance.change_30d_pct: -10.6714, news_check.data.sources.2.snippet).

## Practice trade

- Blocked: judge decided no_trade

## What this cost

- 4 model calls, 24,235 prompt tokens, 1,699 completion tokens, 0.004909 USD as the provider billed it, in 40698 ms.

_Research on read-only RYO evidence. No order was placed. Not financial advice._